How do you compare precast manhole quotes when each supplier builds the structure differently?
Compare the whole structure, not the lines. For each manhole on your list, rebuild every supplier's quote into one assembly at your diameter and depth: base, risers, cone or flat top, adjusting rings, frame and cover, connectors, steps and joint materials. Fill any part a supplier left out with the same marked number for every supplier, then compare the structure totals. Two things go wrong most often: suppliers reach the same depth with different section stacks, and an estimator carries the structure off one line of a quote that prices it in many.
Why don't manhole quotes line up?
A precast manhole is an assembly, and each supplier quotes it its own way.
- Section stacks. One supplier reaches 8 feet with a 3-foot base and one riser. Another uses a 2-foot base and two risers. Both are correct, so the line items do not compare one to one.
- Top section. Eccentric or concentric cone, 2- or 3-foot cone, or a flat slab top. Some city standards call for an eccentric cone unless the plans say otherwise.
- Base. A base with an integral floor, or a separate base slab with a riser on it. A separate base adds a joint and site work.
- Castings.The frame and cover can be on the precast quote, on a separate foundry quote, or “by others”.
- What sits inside the structure. Pipe connectors or boots, steps, invert and benching, and joint sealant or wrap can be quoted, excluded or not mentioned.
- Quote-level terms. Delivery, crane or setting, minimums and the price validity date sit outside the line items.
The general method for any material is in how to compare material vendor quotes. This note covers what is specific to manholes and other precast structures.
How do you rebuild a quote into one structure?
- Write the structure first. Diameter, depth from invert to rim, top type, base type, number and size of pipe openings, and the casting. Take them from the plans, not from the first quote.
- Map every supplier line to a part of that structure. Several lines make one structure. A supplier may group them under one pay item or structure number; keep the group.
- Check that the stack reaches your depth. Add base, risers, top and rings. A stack that is short needs another riser or more rings; one that is long may not fit the rim elevation.
- Fill gaps the same way for every supplier. If one supplier excludes the casting, carry the same marked casting price on every column, or none. Never compare a structure with a casting to one without.
- Compare per structure, then multiply.Total each supplier's structure, then multiply by your count of that structure type. Add delivery and setting before you compare totals.
What does a leveled manhole look like?
This example is invented. The structure and prices are made up to show the method; they are not market prices. Your row: MH-48-08 48-in precast sanitary manhole, 8 ft deep, eccentric cone, 2 pipe openings, 6 EA.
| Part | Supplier A | Supplier B | What leveling shows |
|---|---|---|---|
| Base | 3 ft · $1,180 | 2 ft · $860 | Different stacks. Compare after the stack is complete. |
| Risers | 1 × 2 ft · $320 | 2 × 2 ft · $640 | A: 3 + 2 + 3 = 8 ft. B: 2 + 4 + 2 = 8 ft. Both reach depth. |
| Top | 3 ft eccentric cone · $520 | 2 ft eccentric cone · $430 | Same type, different height; the stack already counts it. |
| Adjusting rings | 2 rings · $90 | Not quoted | B's gap. Carry A's $90 on both columns, marked. |
| Frame and cover | “By others” | 24-in frame and cover · $640 | A's gap. Carry B's $640 on both columns, marked, or your own casting quote on both. |
| Pipe connectors | 2 boots · $210 | 2 boots · $190 | Comparable. |
| Structure, leveled | $2,960 (casting filled) | $2,850 (rings filled) | B is $110 lower per structure once both are complete. |
| × 6 EA | $17,760 | $17,100 | Add delivery and setting before the final comparison. |
On the printed lines alone, Supplier A totals $2,320 and Supplier B $2,760, so A looks $440 cheaper. The missing casting hides the fact that A is the higher structure.
Where does a manhole carry go silently low?
When the estimator carries the structure off one line. A supplier quotes the manhole as a pay item with many lines: base, risers, cone, rings, casting, boots. The estimate has one row for the structure. If that row takes only the line that looks like the structure, such as the base section, the risers, rings and casting drop out. The bid carries a structure for a fraction of its quoted price, and no one sees it until buyout.
Two checks catch it:
- Sum the group. The carried price for a structure equals the sum of every line under its pay item or structure number on the quote, unless a line is excluded on purpose and marked.
- Read the price against the depth. A deep structure carried for the same price as a shallow one is a sign that parts dropped out.
The same pattern applies to other assemblies quoted as many lines: air release valve assemblies, meter vaults, and water and irrigation services.
Should you carry one lump sum or every part?
Most estimates carry one lump-sum row per structure type, because keying every part of every structure takes too long. That is fine when the lump sum is the full sum of the parts and the row names its depth and top. Keep the supplier's part lines with the row. At buyout, suppliers often re-quote, and a new quote can use a different stack; the parts list lets you check the new quote against the structure you carried, not only against a total.
How does Coffer handle this?
Coffer maps supplier quote PDFs to your material list, including assemblies that one supplier quotes in many lines. It maps each part line to the structure row it feeds, prices the row from the sum of its parts, and keeps any quote line that matches no row in view. It recommends a carry; your estimator makes the final decision.
Try mapping a material list and quote, then inspect the matches against your own PDF. For the ongoing service, see features and pricing.
Sources
Public references checked Nov 10, 2026.
- L.B. Foster, CXT 48-inch precast manhole specifications
- Wilbert Precast, Sewer and storm drainage manholes
- City of Galveston, TX, Specification 02601, Precast Concrete Manholes
- City of Shoreline, WA, Precast manhole standard
- American Concrete Pipe Association, Design Data 20: Circular Precast Concrete Manholes
- Coffer field note, How should you compare material vendor quotes? (Aug 30, 2026)
- Coffer field note, How do you level pipe and fittings supplier quotes for a sewer or water main bid? (Oct 14, 2026)